Sicilian Cuisine: Culinary Jewel of the Mediterranean

Estimated reading time: 16 minutes

Sicily is a desirable destination for adventurous travelers, home to sun-soaked beaches, Europe’s largest active volcano, and internationally acclaimed wines, for the gastronomically inclined, Sicilian cuisine offers a vast and diverse selection of dishes.

Guide to Italian Gastronomy and Cuisine: Read more

Thanks to the island’s strategic location in the Mediterranean Sea, roughly 160km northeast of Tunisia, Sicily experienced a tumultuous history. First, the Phoenicians, then the Greeks from the 8th century B.C., colonized the island. Notably, the Greeks brought their olive trees and viticultural practices with them. Next, the Carthaginians and Romans duked it out to control the island during the Punic Wars, and in 945A.D the island fell to Arabs. Then came the Normans and Spaniards. Each culture left its indelible mark on the island’s art, architecture, and cuisine.

In addition to its multicultural heritage, the abundant Sicilian landscape contributes to its vibrant culinary traditions. Mount Etna’s fertile volcanic soil grows a wealth of vegetables and grapes for distinctly Sicilian wines. Plus, there’s an assortment of microclimates for plentiful agriculture, thanks to the island’s varied topography, Mediterranean influence, hot Sirocco winds from Africa, and the Mistral blowing down from the northwest.

The Sicilian Diet 

In Sicily, the diet is primarily based on grains, legumes, and fish. Yet meat and game are available, though generally reserved for special dishes. Regarding vegetables, eggplant is widely incorporated into Sicilian cuisine thanks to the island’s Arab influences. Also heavily included in Sicilian dishes are zucchini, cauliflower, artichoke, broccoli, and bell peppers. Confusingly, broccoli is known as sparaceddi in Sicily, and green cauliflower broccoli and regular cauliflower are vrucculi.

Sicilians rarely cook with butter, unlike the North of Italy. Instead, they use olive oil and flavor their dishes with delicious condiments such as salmoriglio, made from garlic, onions, and lemons. Additionally, anchovies appear in many Sicilian recipes. Lemons and oranges, as do capers, which the Greeks brought to Sicily along with olives, prevail throughout the island. Pistachios are also a quintessential Sicilian ingredient used in both savory recipes and desserts. Varieties from Raffaldi and Bronte are especially sought after. Moreover, the Arabs introduced saffron, couscous, pine nuts, capers, cinnamon, chile peppers, raisins, and candied fruit to the island. Today, these ingredients make Sicilian cuisine markedly diverse and distinctive in respect to other regional Italian cuisines.

Sicilian Cheeses

Caciocavallo cheese is featured prominently in Sicilian cuisine. It’s a cow’s milk cheese eaten as a table cheese when young. As it becomes harder and sharper with age, caciocavallo is often grated over Sicilian pasta dishes. Traditionally, the cheese is formed into balls tied together with raffia palms to make caciocavallo.

Next, ricotta cheese also abounds in Sicily. Ricotta is a twice-cooked creamy curd, hence the name ricotta or recooked. It’s regularly used in both sweet and savory Sicilian recipes. Other notable Sicilian cheeses include:

• Canestrato
• Piacentinu Ennese
• Provola Iblea/Provola Dei Nebrodi
• Ragusano Dop
• Ricotta Infornata
• Vastedda Valle Del Belice

The Best Street Food in Sicily

No Sicilian experience is complete without sampling the plethora of street food the islands have to offer. The street vendors attract potential customers to their respective food stalls with ‘abbanniata,’ a shouted song in the local dialect —the fragrant smells of cipollina and an array of fried Sicilian street foods compounding their efforts. Plan your beach days accordingly because a visit to the capital of street food means it’s time to eat.

Arancina vs. Arancino

East vs. West battle has long been underway in Sicily. The conflict culminates in arguably Sicily’s most famous street food—Arancina. Or is it Arancino? It depends on where you’re eating this deep-fried, breadcrumb-coated rice snack.

Palermo, in the west of the island, makes arancina into a spherical ball. One version sees the rice stuffed with minced meat, while another is decadently filled with béchamel, ham, peas, or mushrooms. Plus, saffron adds a subtle flavor to this famous bite of Sicilian cuisine. To the east, in Catania, Arancino is shaped in pizzo or more of a triangular shape reminiscent of Mount Etna. Meat is also a popular arancino filling in Catania, as is béchamel, butter, and eggplant. However, the jury is still unsure whether the feminine arancina or masculine Arancino is the proper name for this Sicilian street food classic.

 Sfincione

Simplicity can be just as divine with fresh, high-quality ingredients as the most elaborate dish. Sfincione proves as much. The name translates to “thick sponge,” which describes this focaccia-like pizza. The focaccia dough for sfincione is often topped with tomato sauce, onions, anchovies, and caciocavallo. However, variations abound throughout the many cities of Sicily.

Pane e Panelle

Pane e panelle is the fundamental fried street food of Palermo. One that’s sure to have you loosening your belt and returning for seconds. The dish includes fried chickpea pancakes made from a simple batter of chickpea flour and water and served sandwiched between a sesame seed bun savored in Sicily called mafalde. Pane e panelle originated in the kitchens of the poor, as legumes like chickpeas were relied on as a protein source. Today, the dish contributes to the riches of Sicilian cuisine.

Pani Cunzatu

Another dish with humble beginnings, pani cunzatu, or seasoned bread, is the ideal snack to grab while on the go. Bread is seasoned with olive oil, fresh tomatoes, oregano, and anchovies. Optionally, cheese and onions can be added to the mix.

Cipollina

Amongst the street food stalls in Catania, you’ll encounter enticing aromas of sizzling onions thanks to cipollina. The snack rival of Palermo’s sfincione, cipollina is made with sautéed spring onions, tomato sauce, mozzarella, and ham in a crispy, flaky puff pastry crust.

Pidone

Sicily’s region of Messina offers a calzone-like snack called pidone. However, the dough for pidone is much thinner and crispier. These fried delights are shaped like triangles or crescent moons and stuffed with anchovies, curly endive, and tuma, a type of fresh sheep’s cheese.

 Pizzolo

This one-of-a-kind pizza is unique to Sicily, comes in many versions, and can be your appetizer, main course, and dessert. The classic pizzolo is topped with olive oil, oregano, salt, pepper, and Parmigiano Reggiano cheese. The savory version is filled with greens, cheeses, and salami, while the sweet is filled with honey, pistachio cream, or chocolate.

Scaccia

Also known as scacciato or impanata, Scaccia is a delectable gift from the province of Ragusa. Its thin dough is made with water, olive oil, yeast, and flour. Ingredients like ricotta, onion, eggplant, tomato, and sausage are used to fill between layers of the dough, which is folded over itself, resembling the layers of lasagne.

Purpu Vugghiutu

For seafood, look to purpu vugghiutu. This octopus preparation typical of Palermo involves tenderizing the octopus with a beating, then boiling it in salted water until the pink tentacles are cooked and succulent. Purpu vugghiutu is often served with a spritz and lemon for a fresh taste of Sicily.

 

And for Offal Lovers

If you enjoy offal, head to the stigghiularu (traditional Sicilian street food vendor) to snack on stigghiola. These are rolls of entrails, usually from lamb, though chicken and goat stigghiola are also eaten. The entrails are either skewered or wrapped around leeks and onions. Stigghiola is served hot off the grill, garnished with only lemon and salt.

In Palermo, enjoy the highly popular pani câ meusa, a greasy, juicy sandwich of veal entrails. This Sicilian classic is made by boiling the calf’s spleen, lungs, and trachea; when cooked, the offal is sliced into pieces and sandwiched in sesame bread. Pani câ meusa is either served schettu (single – without cheese) or maritatu (married – with cheese) with ricotta or caciocavallo.

If you’re craving meat while perusing the street vendors of Catania, order ‘arrusti e mancia’; this means grill it and eat it. In Catania, horse and donkey meat are very popular. The meat is grilled, sliced, and stuffed into bread without extra garnish or sauces.

The Autista

With such an abundance of mouthwatering food and wine, it’s easy to overeat or overdrink in Sicily. But worry not; the Sicilians have a drink to help with either occasion. The autista, or the driver, is made with lemon juice, soda water, and bicarbonate. The bicarbonate is added last, and you need to drink the autista before the glass bubbles over. The drink was created to sober up those who had over-imbibed. Yet the autista is a miracle worker in digesting and degreasing the stomach after a binge on fried Sicilian street food.

Primi Piatti Siciliani 

 Pasta alla Norma

Though widely savored throughout Sicily today, pasta alla norma was initially created in Catania. This vibrant pasta dish is made by frying eggplant in olive oil and slow-cooking a sauce of tomatoes and basil. The pasta is tossed with the tomato sauce, then the eggplant is added at the end, and the pasta is topped with grated ricotta salata.

Pasta con i Tenerumi

Pasta con i tenerumi is an easy summer meal at the Sicilian table. This one-pot pasta is made with the leaves and shoots of zucchini. First, the zucchini and tenerumi are cooked in a pot of boiling water. Next, the spaghetti, broken into pieces or left whole, is added to the boiling water. Picchi pacchi sauce is also added with tomatoes and garlic browned in olive oil. Once everything is cooked, the dish is finished with a generous grating of caciocavallo or aged ricotta. In effect, pasta con i tenerumi is more of a soup, which some prefer to eat cold when the summer temperatures are high.

Bucatini alla Paolina

This traditional vegetarian pasta from Palermo was created by the friars of the Order of the Minims founded by San Francesco di Paola. Religious orders called for the friars to live a life of obedience, poverty, and chastity. They also had to live a “Lenten life” perpetually, meaning a diet without meat, milk, eggs, or cheese.

A Paolina friar created bucatini alla Paolina to serve his brothers something delicious while adhering to their religious orders. Bucatini alla Paolina incorporates tomato paste, garlic, anchovies, and breadcrumbs. However, cloves and cinnamon are the signature spices of this dish.

Pasta con le Sarde

Pasta con le sarde is another essential dish in Sicilian cuisine. It’s known as a dish of Mari e Monti, or “of seas and mountains,” because it includes wild fennel, which is not found on the coast. This Sicilian specialty is traditionally prepared with bucatini, sardines (plentiful in Sicily), and wild fennel. Additional ingredients include raisins, pine nuts, salted anchovies, saffron, and breadcrumbs. In Sicily, toasted breadcrumbs are called muddica atturata or cheese of the poor people.

A few variants of pasta con le sarde are savored throughout the island. The Trappitara version from Trappeto in Palermo is the most classic and served in bianco. Messina’s recipe omits saffron, while the Milanese version incorporates tomato sauce and salted sardines.

Busiate alla Siciliana

While in Sicily, tasting pesto alla Trapanese is a must. This unique pesto from Trapani is made by working garlic, almonds, basil, cherry tomatoes, olive oil, and salt into a paste with a mortar and pestle. Typically, pesto alla trapanese is served with busiate pasta. The pesto clings to all the nooks and crannies of this rolled-corkscrew-shaped pasta for the perfect flavor-packed bite.

Pasta ‘ ncasciata

A specialty of Messina, pasta ‘ncasciata takes its name from the unique cooking technique used to make the classic dish. To prepare pasta ‘ncasciata, ground beef, onions, white wine, and tomatoes are placed in a casserole dish. The casserole is covered in hot embers and simmered to create a ragù. Maccheroni pasta cooked very al dente is tossed with the ragù, fried eggplant, and caciocavallo cheese. Grated parmigiano reggiano cheese tops the dish and is baked until golden brown.

Other variations include ‘ncasciata from Palermo, which is made with tomato sauce and sausage, salami, or ham. Meanwhile, ‘ncasciata from Enna foregoes tradition, opting for cauliflower and pecorino cheese.

 Couscous Trapanese

In Sicilian cuisine, couscous is cooked in a traditional low and wide terracotta bowl with flared edges called a mafaradda. Couscous and hot, salted water are added to the mafaradda and stirred around by hand until the couscous is ready. Couscous from Trapani incorporates a fish soup made with red snapper or sea bass, celery, onion, bay leaf, tomato, garlic, and parsley.

Secondi Piatti Siciliani 

Mulincianeddi Chini

This stuffed eggplant dish is typical of Sicilian cuisine and known as melanzane ripiene in traditional Italian. The eggplant is filled with a mixture of its pulp, Parmigiano Reggiano, garlic, and breadcrumbs and then slowly roasted until lusciously tender.

Agghiotta

This fish stew from Messina is made with salted northern cod, a legacy from when the Normans ruled the island. The cod first needs time to soak. Then it’s cooked with potatoes, tomato, onion, celery, and olives. Plus, pine nuts, raisins, and capers are the trademark ingredients of Sicilian cuisine. Agghiotta can also be prepared with tuna and swordfish. However, the dish is only prepared with onions, celery, tomatoes, capers, and black olives.

Sarde a Beccafico

Sarde a beccafico is a traditional dish that embodies the agrodolce (sweet and sour), symbolizing the flavor contrasts in Sicilian cuisine. Historically, social class indicated the types of food typically eaten. The nobility and elite ate foods higher and closer to the sky, i.e., birds. In contrast, the lower class ate what was lower to the ground, such as sardines. The name of this dish comes from the beccafico, a small bird traditionally eaten by the nobility. There are many versions of sarde a beccafico in Sicily. Palermo’s take on this baked specialty includes butterflied sardines stuffed with a mixture of breadcrumbs, garlic, sugar, parsley, and pine nuts.

 Involtini di Pesce Spada

Involtini di pesce spada is another delightful seafood recipe from Sicily. This plate features pieces of swordfish stuffed with breadcrumbs, raisins, and pine nuts. The swordfish involtini are skewered with bay leaves between each piece of fish for enhanced aromatics and then baked.

Pesce Spada alla Siciliana

This classic Sicilian swordfish recipe involves olives, tomatoes, capers, garlic, celery, vinegar, and pine nuts. These ingredients are sautéed in olive oil and then simmered in water. Once the water evaporates, the swordfish steaks are cooked in the same pan. To serve, pesce spada alla Siciliana is topped with a tangy, flavorful sauce.

Calamari Ripieni

In Sicily, calamari is stuffed with the typical Sicilian filling of breadcrumbs, parsley, capers, olive oil, and occasionally pine nuts. They can be cooked in a tomato sauce or, as in Messina, in a sugo alla ghiotto or greedy sauce, a tasty sauce made with celery, onion, capers, olives, tomatoes, and olive oil.

Polpette all’Agrodolce

These sweet and sour Sicilian meatballs are made from a mixture of beef, eggs, pine nuts, cinnamon, salt, pepper, and amaretti cookies that have been soaked in milk. The polpette is deep-fried and finished with a sauce made from sugar, vinegar, capers, olives, pine nuts, and onions for that signature agrodolce flavor of Sicilian cuisine.

Coniglio alla Siciliana

Another agrodolce meat dish enjoyed in Siciliy is Coniglio alla Siciliana. First, a soffrito of onions, carrots, and celery is made to prepare the dish. Then, the rabbit is salted and slowly cooked with soffrito, capers, wine, sugar, vinegar, pine nuts, and raisins.

Farsumagru

This is a hearty meat dish known as farsumagru in the Sicilian dialect or falsomagro in traditional Italian. The name means fake lean; the dish looks lean from the outside yet is filled with quite the riches. Farusmagru is a meat roll stuffed with hard-boiled eggs, cheese, prosciutto, and peas. The meat roll is baked and then served on a platter. While baking, farsumagru releases flavor-packed juices served over pasta for the first course.

Dolci Siciliani 

Cannoli

Famous and adored the world over, cannoli is easily the most iconic dessert of Sicily. Traditionally, a connolo is a rolled, tube-shaped fried dough filled with fresh ricotta and decorated with candied orange peel. Other variations incorporate crushed pistachios, chocolate, and other candied fruits.

Cassata Siciliana

Cassata is also a contender for the quintessential Sicilian dessert. A colorful creation representative of the island’s vibrancy, cassata’s time-consuming preparation makes it even more special. This dessert involves a liqueur-soaked sponge cake concealed under a green-rimmed, candied fruit-topped marzipan exterior. Ricotta and chocolate chips enliven the sponge cake.

The iconic Sicilian dessert speaks to the multicultural heritage of the island. The name cassata comes from the Arabic word quas’at, the cylinder-shaped metal mold used to make casseroles and cakes. During the Norman period, the nuns of the Martorana convent in Palermo developed marzipan from a mixture of almond flour and sugar. In contrast, the Spaniards brought sponge cake and chocolate to the island. The lavish and exquisite cassata Siciliana, as adored today, evolved into a true masterpiece during the Baroque period.

Also, keep an eye out for Casatelle of Sant’Agata prepared in Catania for its patron saint. Known as minnuzze ri Sant’Ajita in dialect, these sponge cake, ricotta, and chocolate desserts are covered in marzipan and topped with a candied cherry. They’re meant to resemble the breasts of Sant’Agata, which were amputated during martyrdom.

Granita

Prominent in eastern Sicily, granita is the ideal dessert to enjoy under the hot Sicilian sun. The Arabs introduced this cool “flavored snow” dessert. Supposedly, ice was historically cut from the tops of mountains and brought down to the villages to be crushed and flavored for granita. Today, many granita flavors exist in eastern Sicily, such as lemon, coffee, watermelon, almond, peach, strawberry, prickly pear, and more. Sicilian granita is not a slushy but a dense and creamy treat accompanying brioche for breakfast.

Frutta Martorana

These marzipan sweets prominent in Palermo and Messina are true works of art. Frutta Martorana originated in the Martorana monastery in Palermo, where nuns would decorate the barren trees in the courtyard with fruit-shaped marzipan sweets to impress visiting archbishops. Eventually, the nuns began to sell the frutta Martorana, which became a great income source for the church. This specialty is especially prevalent in Sicilian pastry shops on All Saints’ Day.

 Sfoglio di Polizzi

In the Madonnie mountain range in the north-central part of the island, you’ll find sfoglio di Polizzi, known as sfùagghiu, in the local dialect. The sponge cake dessert is filled with chocolate, cinnamon, and a fresh sheep’s cheese called tuma. Sfoglio di Polizzi was created by the nuns of the Santa Margherita convent in honor of their patron saint.

Zeppole di Riso

Zeppole di riso are tasty fried rice pancakes initially served in the 16th century by the nuns of the Benedictine Monastery in Catania. The zeppole dough is made from rice, milk, and orange zest. After being fried, the zeppole di riso is garnished with orange honey and icing sugar for Sicilian cuisine’s unique, sweet taste.

Sfinci di Ricotta

Ricotta makes its way into another scrumptious fried Sicilian dessert called sfinci. The ancient Sicilian recipe is often prepared around Carnival. The dough for sfinci is made from ricotta, flour, sugar, eggs, and baking soda. Occasionally, they’re enriched with raisins. The dough is shaped into small balls, fried until golden brown, and sprinkled with sugar for an addictive dessert you can’t stop eating.